I've been working on mystery quilts this week. I'm up to clue 3 in Charlotte's Stars Around the Corner, I really don't know if this will be the layout, but it's a pretty good guess. Charlotte's mysteries tend to be set on point.
http://scrapitudequilts.com/about-scrapitude-quilts-and-me/
One of the things I like about Charlotte's quilts is that she talks more about value than color. Value and good contrast are important to a successful scrap quilt. My Stars Around the Corner quilt has all kinds of scraps in it: batiks, Civil War prints, novelty prints, blenders, and a full range of uglies, but I can already tell this one is going to work.
Unlike Gyleen's Bricks,Cobblestones and Pebbles, which I consider a scrap quilt fail.
The only directions we were given for this quilt were to chose a soloist fabric and not to use the soloist in the rest of the quilt. We were encouraged to use disparate scraps, but this approach didn't work for me. I've seen this pattern work well with a controlled color palette. but if a designer of a mystery says any scraps will do, I trust the designer. This quilt top is a good size now for donation, but I have already made more of the nine patches and a few of the kleenex box blocks. So I need to decide whether to do the next round or not.
I think quilt fails are a necessary part of quilting. If you've never had one, maybe you aren't stretching yourself. Get out of your box and try something new with your scraps. They are just sitting there taking up space. Use them up and donate the top if you don't like it. An ugly quilt will keep someone warm just as well as a beautiful quilt. My BC&P quilt would be great to take to a soccer game, the beach or on a picnic. I might keep it in the trunk of my car or send it to college with my son. It's the kind of quilt that a kid could spill red kool aid on, and you wouldn't really care.